Best Oatmeal Cookies Ever?

A life-long friend of mine knows I’m into food blogging. So when she came across a recipe that said it was “The Best Oatmeal Cookie Recipe We’ve Ever Tried,” she passed it along my way. How sweet is that? Thank you Monica! Of course, being a fan of oatmeal raisin cookies, I had to try it. The recipe came from the Wall Street Journal. I don’t know if I’ve ever made a recipe of theirs before. Apparently there is a newly opened restaurant in Manhattan, and rumor has it they have a good cookie!

The first thing I noticed that was different from what I’ve done before is that the instructions said to soak the raisins in hot water for 30 minutes. I wondered if that would make the raisins juicy and plump? I wasn’t disappointed- I do think it made a difference! They also mentioned using old fashioned or rolled oats, which I always do, and agree that they are best for oatmeal cookies. The recipe called for adding the egg and vanilla at the end, after adding the oats and raisins; that was another thing I had never done before. Lastly it was recommended to allow the batter to sit for 4 days, which I will admit I did not do, although it gave me a pass. Something I would not do is bake them again for 17 minutes. There was no leeway. The directions specifically said 17 minutes, and that was too long, at least for my pans and oven- unless my goal was awesome granola.

The result was delicious, almost candy like. They kind of had a shiny sweet exterior that I thought was different from my regular batches. The cookies were big and chewy (when cooked about 14-15 minutes). And I have to say my kids loved them. They baked round and flat and firm. To be completely honest I think they are perfect for ice cream sandwiches! And although I am not disappointed, my quest for the perfect oatmeal raisin cookie is still on. Of course I have been heavily persuaded by the organic “Aussie Bites” from Costco. I think they’re on to something! However, my dad disagrees whole-heartedly. This much I know is true: personal taste is subjective. Am I rambling?

As Seen in the Wall Street Journal:

Active Time: 10-15 minutes Total Time: 1 hour, plus 4 days for chilling dough Makes: 14 cookies

1 cup raisins
1¼ cups all-purpose flour
1 tablespoon plus 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
2 teaspoons baking soda
1½ teaspoons fine sea salt
1½ sticks slightly softened butter
1 cup light brown sugar, firmly packed
6 tablespoons granulated sugar
2 cups old-fashioned or rolled oats
1 extra-large egg
1½ teaspoons vanilla extract

1. Soak raisins in hot water for 30 minutes, then drain.

2. Meanwhile, in a small bowl, sift together flour, cinnamon, baking soda and salt.

3. Using an electric mixer fitted with paddle attachment, cream together butter and sugars on medium speed until light and fluffy, scraping down frequently. Take care not to overbeat.

4. Add flour mixture to creamed butter and sugar and mix on low speed until combined. Mix in oats, followed by drained raisins, egg and vanilla.

5. Use a ¼-cup measure to scoop dough onto a parchment-paper lined baking sheet. Flatten each blob with base of measuring cup. Cover baking sheet with plastic wrap and refrigerate 4 days (optional).

6. To bake cookies: Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Bake until cookies are golden-brown on the outside but still soft in the middle, about 17 minutes. Remove from oven and let rest on baking sheet a few minutes, then transfer to a rack to cool.

—Adapted from Melissa Weller of Sadelle’s, New York City

Thank you Monica! This was a lot of fun!

21 comments

  1. Sounds like a different recipe for sure but looks like they turned out well! Thanks for reviewing this recipe! I might try them, they would be a nice little change! I can’t imagine waiting 4 days and it sounds like they turned out well without doing that!

    1. Thanks Lynn:) I really think they’d be great for sandwich-ing vanilla ice cream! (Maybe just a little smaller.) I know 4 days is a lot when you want to eat cookies! But the recipe gave allowance for proceeding if you couldn’t wait, thankfully! 😉

  2. When I was in Jr. High my Mom gave me my 1st Cookbook and it has a wonderful recipe for Oactmeal Raisin Cookies…ill look it up & come back with it in a few for you.

  3. I pinned this and will try it as I am on the same quest, lol. So far, I still like Joy of Cooking’s oatmeal cookies the best. I agree, this is a very subjective topic:)

  4. Sounds yummy, Sadie! I really like the idea of trying them as ice-cream sandwiches! 🙂 I would have a very hard time waiting four days to cook them, too! I have a hard enough time not eating cookie dough out of the bowl! 😉 (unless it’s egg-less cookies, then I totally do!!) 😀

  5. These look really good! I rarely make oatmeal cookies (regular chocolate chip being the favorite around here), but really want to more. I’ll have to try soaking the raisins first. 🙂

Leave a Reply