I’ve only attempted fudge a few times in my life- and not very successfully. It seems like it should just be something in one’s repertoire. Like every homemaker makes fudge, at least in my mind. Once I even tried making a sugar-free fudge for my diabetic grandmother, which was a disaster. I live hours away from Mackinac Island, where they produce world famous and delicious fudge. It’s just like one of those things that has been a part of my life all of my life. Making good fudge is important! Is it a Michigan thing? Is any of this making sense?
Then came Anna of Life Bellissima. She shared a Peanut Butter Fudge recipe that was special to her, because it’s the same recipe her dad used to make. And I thought to myself, “I’m going to try again.” And I can now feel comfortable saying that I do make fudge- good fudge, successfully (at least one kind of it). I have my own family recipe! My husband and kids loved it, and my kids had fun helping me make it.
My favorite tip was that Anna said to pour it onto a plate! My first reaction was no way, it’s going to go everywhere and make a hot mess! But, mind you, I’ve never been successful at fudge making. And I thought about the times I’ve tried to dig it out of a baking dish… or try to prep a dish with wax paper. And I trust Anna, and if she said that’s how she does it, then by golly that’s how I’ll do it! I dumped that hot peanut butter fudge right onto a large (buttered) dinner plate, and it worked!
Without further ado, straight from Life Bellissima:
Sue’s Easy 15-Minute Peanut Butter Fudge
*I prefer to use organic ingredients
-In medium saucepan, combine:
1 cup raw cane sugar
1 cup light brown sugar
1/4 teaspoon salt
1/2 cup milk
-Stir with a wooden spoon until mixture begins to softly boil. Cook to 240 degrees. (For some reason, mine tends to heat fairly quickly, and I take it off of the burner at 230 degrees.)
-Remove from heat, and add:
1 cup mini marshmallows (or homemade marshmallow recipe here)
1/2 cup peanut butter
1 teaspoon vanilla
-Mix with a wooden spoon for several minutes. Candy will become creamy, thicken and start to lose it’s gloss.
-Spread onto a buttered dish (Dad and I always used a large dinner plate.)
-This recipe can easily be doubled.
Thank you Anna for a great new recipe!
And I’ve had a request for Life Bellissima’s Homemade Marshmallow recipe too. Which she got from www.kitchenfrau.com, who got the no-fail recipe from her mother-in-law, Mabel’s cookbook. Don’t you just love modern conveniences? She includes some great step-by-step photos too. (Just click on the website above!)
Oh the fudge looks delicious Sadie, and those sweet munchkins sure look excited at having given you a hand in the process. Well done!
Thank you Loretta, we did have fun! And my kids are always like “Can we eat now?” Meaning, are you done taking pictures yet? Lol.
I know the feeling, us bloggers do put our families out don’t we? 🙂 Pictures are sooooo important 🙂
Lol! It just goes with the job. ?
Lol … my girls will ask the same thing! And then Jonathan waits patiently at the dinner table like he’s (somewhat) used to it. Ha! 😉
Peanut butter is my favourite! These fudges look soooooooo cute and yummmmmmm!
Thank you Lina! ?
Great pictures… And great fudge! Look at you two little helpers! That’s really cool…
I get a lot of help around here!
That fudge looks so good, you know I have only made fudge once in my life and I don’t know why I don’t make it more often. This looks delicious,
Thank you! It’s an easy recipe to follow if you plan on trying again!
Your helpers are the absolute cutest!! I’ve never made fudge successfully before, but this looks good!! And Anna is so sweet.
You got this Jasmine 😉 And thank you!
I totally LOVE fudge !!!! I have no idea why, but I tend to make fudge only once a year for Christmas !!! (weird hey…guess that will now change 🙂 )
It does seem like it’s popular that time of year! We get it all summer long too!
Sadie, you are so sweet!! 😀 Your post has made my week, and I absolutely love the pictures of your sweet kiddos helping!! My Dad would love this so much, too … knowing that others were happily enjoying his favorite candy!! Big hugs, dear Sadie!! 😀
So glad you shared it with the rest of us! ? I understand why he liked it! God bless you and your family!
God bless you all, too, sweet Sadie! 🙂 I noticed Naomi’s “thumbs up” now … sooo cute! 😉
??
This sounds wonderful – I love Peanut Butter!
Thank you spearfruit! I hope it went well for you today!
Thanks Sadie, I will have a post soon about my visit. I appreciate you asking about it!
I confess I have never made fudge before. Now I don’t even have an excuse! p.s. Your two helpers are adorable!
Thanks foodie blogger! It’s worth the effort!
Love this fudge! yumm
It’s good stuff! 😉 Hi Lynn!
Yeah I love it!
I remember Anna writing about the memories of her dad making this fudge! Love seeing your sweet babes making memories too! I do make chocolate fudge, but clearly need to expand my repertoire! ?
? I need your recipe so I can expand mine!
Will do, Sadie! Just in time for Valentine’s Day… ❤️
Great! ????
YAS! I love me some fudge. Can’t wait to try out this recipe 🙂
Lol! It’s a good one! ?
The fudge looks amazing Sadie! I would never have thought to pour hot fudge on a plate. How interesting! Great pictures…your little ones are adorable!
Thank you Antonia! It was a great tip, I wouldn’t have thought of that either!
Seeing this means I need to go make fudge now! It looks wonderful!
? And I need to make some more!
As always, looks so good Sarah:) I’m with you about Michigan fudge…whenever we go to Mackinac Island, I always have to pick like 5 kinds, and at least 2 with peanut butter in them ? Unfortunately, I’m not nearly as skilled as you in the kitchen, but if I ever get there I’ll try this recipe!!
Oh that’s not true about you in the kitchen! I’ve seen your work! But the Mackinac fudge part, that I can believe! 😉
This fudge was really good! It’s always fun to go your house and sample a treat like this.
Thanks Pops:)
Do you know how upset I am right now that my daughter is allergic to peanuts! Well, my son would love this! Thanks for the recipe. 🙂
? I have a son who is allergic to milk! No milk chocolate, no cheese… Thanks Nicky!
Peanutbutter fudge – the ultimate decadence. I cannot wait to try to make it. And those darling angels pictures were as sweet as the fudge.
? thank you Bernadette!